AKC
  Greyhound
  Controversy
   
Chronology |  GCA Membership |  Secret Insights |  GCA Officers |  Inbreeding Stats |  Health Issues |  Breeders Write |  Anti-NGA Views |  Replies to Antis |  Canadian Views |  Notable Dogs |  Photo Quiz |  NGA Dogs at Shows |  Site Map |  Home  
Greyhound Club of America Membership Statistics

The Greyhound Club of America, like most breed clubs, does not publish announcements when it rejects applicants to the club. However, some members have reviewed the minutes of the GCA Board and the official club news pages published in the newsletter, and have discussed the history of applications to the club with members of long standing. The following tables provide twelve years of statistics on approvals and rejections of applicants for club membership.

From the year 1990 through 2000, only three applicants for membership in the Greyhound Club of America were refused. However, in 2001 through the first 9 months of 2002, there have been 11 refusals.

Of the 2002 applicants, the majority of those accepted for membership had sponsors who were officers or Board members of the GCA. All of the rejected applicants were sponsored by members who have objected to the Board's vote to close the stud book to Greyhounds registered with the National Greyhound Association

The GCA Constitution and Bylaws require that membership applications be discussed at board meetings, but the recent rejections of applications were done without any discussion at a meeting. The votes were conducted by email, and the actual vote tallies have not been disclosed. The GCA Board voted in 1994 to keep their meetings open during the discussions of prospective members. This was done to prevent someone from being blackballed by rumor or innuendo that could not be substantiated if subjected to public scrutiny. The current GCA Board has chosen to ignore this rule and has conducted their discussions and voting on new members in private.

The current GCA Standing Rules include the following:

"Membership applications will not be considered until board members have reviewed all pertinent information and that information has been published in the newsletter."

"The Recording Secretary shall initiate and report out all balloting by any means."
No negative information was published in the newsletter about any of the recently rejected applicants, yet they were voted down. The Board votes on membership applications were not "reported out", and applicants and sponsors have been unable to learn the reasons or the votes which resulted in the applications being rejected.

It was suggested by one club officer that the current year's number of applications was unusually large. There is some irony in that claim. There have been 17 membership applications voted on by the GCA Board so far this year. By way of comparison, GCA board member Shari Mason, her husband, and her daughter were all welcomed into the club in a year when 20 new members were inducted. Treasurer Herman Leider, as well as Board member Mary Ellen Gorske and her spouse joined the GCA in 1994, when 22 new members were accepted. And club president Sue LeMieux was accepted in 1995, a year when 13 new members joined.

GCA membership applications by year
Year     Applications   Accepted   Refused
1990 13 13 0
1991 22 20 2
1992 17 17 0
1993 9 9 0
1994 22 22 0
1995 13 13 0
1996 5 5 0
1997 6 6 0
1998 7 7 0
1999 7 7 0
2000 9 8 1
2001 9 8* 1
2002 17 7 10
      * 1 honorary member

GCA Membership Details

The following information is taken from GCA Newsletters held by the GCA Archives and cover the years 1990 through 2002. Policy was instituted by the Board in February of 1990 to print the names of all applicants for membership in the GCA Newsletter.

1990 - 13 applicants accepted, 0 refused
Voted in: Jon Cole
Susan Cole
Geri Ann Etheredge
Sheila Grant
Mrs. M.J. Kessler
Eric Liebes
Nancy Liebes
Jack Mitchell
Margaret Mitchell
James S. Porcher
Katherine Settle
Bob Gilb
Sharon Gilb

1991 - 20 applicants accepted, 2 refused
Voted in: Marti Bradford
Henry C. Clark
Linda Colflesh
Cheryl DiBiase
Hillary Knoeppel
Jaana Laato-Huvinen (Finland)
Theresa Strain
Dr. Thomas Strain
Robert Mason
Shari Mason
Stacy R. Mason
Bill St. Michel
Lyn St. Michel (now Martin)
Georgianna Mueller
Joyce Pollard (died October, 1991)
K. Dale Baer
Arthur Kos
William Simpson
Pat Simpson
Dr. Bradley Spak

1992 - 17 applicants accepted, 0 refused
Voted in: Sharon Allert
Margaret Bryson
Linda Carlson
Greg Davis
Anita Dengler
Annie Fitt
Glenna Gilb
Nancy Hahn
Helen Hamilton DVM
Lisa Jo Helgesen
Mrs. Julian (Mary) Keevil
Amy Leider
Robert B. Lucas
Kari J. Mastrocola
Roger Owens
Hubert M. Thomas
Madison M. Weeks

1993 - 9 applicants accepted, 0 refused
Voted in: Dorothy Aversa
Jennifer Aversa
Dani Creech
Margaret Harris
Paul Huddleston
Sheila Huddleston
Ruth Lasso
Laurie Richer
Marsha Freitag Wartell

1994 - 22 applicants accepted, 0 refused
Voted in: Donald Aronson
Cecelia Barnett
Kathy Beliew
Dee Dee Colella
Paul Everitt
Cathy Gaidos
James Gaidos
Dr. Kenneth Gorske
Mary Ellen Gorske
Lisa Hovelsrud
Julian Keevil
Herman Leider
Tad Lowdermilk
Joan Malak
Deborah Park
David Rumel
Bonnie Lee Saher
Ann Schoolcraft
S. Richard Schweizer
John Shontz
Bob Urban
Isabelle Zimmerman

1995 - 13 applicants accepted, 0 refused
Voted in: Lois T. Bires
Ian Bond
Susan E. Crutcher
Kimberly A. Fritzler
Dr. Shelley Gremillion
Kimberly A. Hamm
Kathleen Helmke
Susan Keenan
Susan LeMieux
John A. Malak
Linda Martinez
Pamela Rubinstein
Patricia Stevenson

1996 - 5 applicants accepted, 0 refused
Voted in: Jaqui Bradshaw
Jon Bradshaw
Carol J. Curlee
John Palmer
Kathleen (Kat) Whitaker

1997 - 6 applicants accepted, 0 refused
Voted in: Penny Bolt
Tammy Farrington
Dana Olson
Roseann Raduskas
Melanie Steele
Sally Taylor

1998 - 7 applicants accepted, 0 refused
Voted in: Cathleen (Kate) Antolick
James W. Augustus
Rose Mary Conner
Terry Fletcher
Lisa Hall
Ric Metts
Zoran Sordjan

1999 - 7 applicants accepted, 0 refused
Voted in: Joy Brown
Pio Galli
Beth Levine
Mary Jane Peterson
Ted Peterson
Miguel Seco
Mari Lewis-Villalpando

2000 - 8 applicants accepted, 1 refused
Voted in: Karen Beard
Cynthia Bellis-Jones
Angela Cockburn
Pam Davis
Glen Davis
Bill Hempel
Jack Steele
Judy Jones Tisdale

2001 - 8 applicants accepted (including 1 honorary), 1applicant refused
Voted in: Mrs. Phillip S.P. Fell (honorary)
Joan Goldstein
Darlene L. Klein
David L. Klein
Mindy M. Liebau
Jane Ragusano
Susan Usseglio
Sheryl Bartel
Reinstated: Linda Carlson

2002 (as of 1 Nov 02) - 7 applicants accepted, 10 refused
Voted in: Karen Hagios
Steven E. Johnson
Pam Lejman
Beverley Lodesol
Ron Lodesol
Joe Purkheiser
Muriel Purkheiser

A few years back, a GCA committee proposed altering the club constitution to add a new class of "associate members" and to impose more stringent requirements for full membership. This proposal was intended to limit full membership to what the committee considered to be "the most serious fanciers of the Greyhound breed." The general membership voted against these changes. Now it seems that the directors of the club have imposed barriers to membership that are even more restrictive.

Most of the applicants rejected in the past year have considerable experience in the breed. All owned show champions and many owned coursing champions as well. Some rejected applicants had over 25 years experience showing and breeding Greyhounds, and in many cases, the applicants turned down in the past year had more experience in the breed than the GCA directors who were voting on their applications.

There appears to be a bias among the GCA's directors to reject applicants who may favor keeping the stud book open. It is a violation of the Greyhound Club of America's duty to the breed to reject experienced, qualified fanciers of diverse opinions solely because of their views on a single controversial matter.

In October 2002, the Insights Document came to light. This document was secretly used by the GCA Board to evaluate recent candidates for club membership. It's worth noting that the membership criteria used in 2002 are considerably different from those listed in the GCA bylaws. Oddly, the applicants for membership were judged as worthy or not based on research done by a club officer without directly asking the applicants or their sponsors for the data sought. Although the club was advised in 2000 that earning a show championship could not be used as a criteria for membership, this document not only tries to count the number of Greyhound show champions finished by each applicant but it does not accept all show champions as equal. It counts championships separately depending on whether the dog's pedigree includes NGA dogs in the most recent four generations.

Application for Greyhound Club of America membership

Chronology of events related to Greyhound stud book closure

Revised, 4 November 2002, S. Pober

  AKC
  Greyhound
  Controversy
   
Chronology |  GCA Membership |  Secret Insights |  GCA Officers |  Inbreeding Stats |  Health Issues |  Breeders Write |  Anti-NGA Views |  Replies to Antis |  Canadian Views |  Notable Dogs |  Photo Quiz |  NGA Dogs at Shows |  Site Map |  Home  

© 2002 S. Pober