| Cigar | Look | Draw | Burn | Strength | Aftertaste | Rating | Flavor |
| Henry Clay Corona size (Dominican) |
Poor | good | good | ** | awful and lingering | worse cigar I have smoked | musty old mold taste |
| Avo #2
(Dominican) |
great | great | great | **** | tasty | **** | good flavor but a less than complex finish |
| Artero Fuenta reserve rothschild (Dominican) |
poor | good | good | ** | average | * * | poorly constructed and inconsistent, one unraveled flavor really good but wrapper fragile |
| Romeo e Jullietta Churchill
(Cuban) |
excellent | great | ok | **** * | great | ***** | really tasty cigar, creamy, spice and complex WOW |
| V Centenial corona size
|
good |
awful | poor | ok | ok | 0 | unsmokable due to a tight draw. |
| Dunhill 6x50
|
good |
good | even | ***1/2 | good | **** | Mild not complex at the start. Built to a really good long smoke |
| H. Upmann Churchill
|
good |
excellent | even | *** | a tad strong and lingering | *** | Strong finish. A strong golf cigar. Taste not enough for after dinner |
| Cussano Hermanos
|
excellent |
awful | uneven | ? | ? | 0 | Unable to smoke |
| Cigar | Look | Draw | Burn | Strength | Aftertaste | Rating | Flavor |
| JR Hondoran Supreme
|
Bad |
Even | Even | Mild ** |
None | **1/2 | Mild very little complexity |
| Astral Churchill size
|
Smooth well done |
Even | Less than even some tunneling | medium *** |
Mild Lingering | ** | Not very complex, a nice finish |
| Montecristo Cuban (a gift) @46x5 1/2 |
Less than perfect but still good |
Perfect | Even | **** | Excellent | ***** | Strong and complex coffee bean and cream |
| Butera Royal Vintage |
Great |
Even | Even | ** | Pleasant | ** | OK cigar but not worth the money. Little complexity |
| La Gloria Cubana
|
Great |
Even | Even | ***1/2 | Pleasant | **** | Good, Peppery taste. Good finish; reminds me of Cohiba |
| Saint Luis Rey Series A
|
Good |
some good and some tight | some even and some uneven | **** | Good | **** | Pretty strong and complex full flavored cigar. Tastes great |
| H Uppman Monarch
|
Great |
Even | Even | *** | Eh | *** | Not much flavor |
| Cohiba Robusto
|
Good |
Perfect | Even | ***** | Good | ***** | WOW! Very strong flavor with lots of pepper. Great for after a big meal. Where can I get more? |
| Cigar | Look | Draw | Burn | Strength | Aftertaste | Rating | Flavor |
| Ashton 898
|
Great |
Great | Even | Mild ** |
Mild to bitter | ** | Too mild, very little flavor, typical Dominican |
| Don Tomas Special Edition 500 |
Great |
Good | ?Even | *** | Good | ***1/2 | Pretty good flavor some complexity. Used to be excellent choice for $, now not worth it |
| Partagas #10
|
Great |
Good to Bad | Even | *** | Good | *** | This is supposed to be a great cigar. Very inconsistent in roll. |
| La Cosecha Robusto size New Nicaraguan |
Good |
Even | Even | ** | Mild | ** | Not the density of smoke, flavor or finish or a great cigar |
| Juan Clemente
|
Good |
Even | Even | ** | Mild | *** | Good Cigar for afternoon or before meals, Price is too high for flavor |
| Remedios maduro | Great | Good | Even | *** | Tasty | ***** | Needed aging but after a couple of months they were great |
| Berring in Glass Tube | Really Good | Great | Great | ** | Good | **** | A nice suprise |
| Mercedes Torpedo | Great | Good | Good | *** | Good | **** | Expensive but fairly good |